I do however think I will record something to let everyone hear what im talking about.. Psychological: If you struggle to play a tune on an instrument and sing a harmony, you will also struggle with whistling and humming different notes.
You may need to work on developing a sense for harmony before you can do anything interesting. Physical: The notes you make with whistling and humming occupy the same air, and so interfere with each other. If you sing tenor, then the whistled and hummed notes are relatively close to each other, and the interference between them will make the whistling harder. If you sing a deep bass, you will have an easier time of it.
As for performance, you can find a few youtube videos lately on the subject I found two that were relatively good. If you have a particularly spectacular whistle and voice, you may just be able to attract an audience. You may need to add some percussion, and then bill yourself as a one-man-band. When I whistle and hum, with great virtuosity if you ask me, nobody is particularly impressed - it is fun though, and best done in the shower. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top.
Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. Why can't I whistle and hum different notes at the same time? Ask Question. Asked 10 years, 4 months ago. Active 4 years, 6 months ago. Viewed 10k times. Improve this question.
In the lab, we had people listen to simple melodies then try to sing or whistle the melodies back. We compared the pitches of target notes with the pitches that people actually sang or whistled.
Humans spend hours each day controlling the pitch of their voices — conveying love, sadness and anger. Despite all this practice, people were closer to the target note when they were whistling. This tells us that the human skill with the voice evolved after our ancestors split from other apes. These studies also tell us that control over the lips evolved much earlier, and we think that this might explain our findings. It could also be that the larynx is tuned just well enough for speech and for many of us, singing just asks a little too much.
The answer is that the voice carries a lot more information than just high and low pitches. We use the placement of our lips and tongue to amplify some parts of our voice and dampen others. This is how we build up the sounds that we use to speak. Whistles on the other hand are very simple sounds, and there is not much room for the rich acoustic tapestry of speech. Whistles may carry less information than the voice, but they will carry much further.
That can be handy when your friends are out of earshot — or rather voice-shot. Kotz was originally published on The Conversation. Other instruments like the violin or trombone make a continuous range of sounds, just like the voice.
They can also sound off key, by making the same kind of mistakes as a singer does. Still, it turns out that instrumentalists play closer to their musical targets than singers. That is, singers are more likely to miss their note than violinists, for example.
Violins and trombones are built for the express purpose of making musical sounds. With an appropriately tuned instrument, placing a bow over the strings in a certain way ought to be pretty consistent in the sound that it makes. The pitch of your voice comes from your larynx sometimes called the voice box. When air passes between a pair of membranes in the larynx, they vibrate like a comb and wax-paper kazoo.
Just like the kazoo, when these membranes are stretched, they make a higher pitch, and when they are relaxed, they make a lower pitch. Try it, no more vibration, right? But the voice has a disadvantage. The larynx is controlled by a complicated and interconnected set of muscles. Whether one muscle raises or lowers the pitch of your voice can depend on what the other muscles are doing. Also, these are muscles! They get tired if you use them too much. They change as we grow, learn and age.
For me, my first note was G6 so anything lower is a bit harder to control. When hitting whistle notes it helps to, in a sense, "visualize" the notes going higher. That is what I do when I reach notes past C7. If it feels uncomfortable immediately stop. Focus on the F6 note, for example, instead of anything higher until you are very comfortable hitting said note. It is very common for vocal coaches to say whistle register is bad for you, but I have been hitting whistle notes for 7 years now and I have actually been improving, not getting worse.
It's much easier for me to hit whistle notes now and there is no decrease in the quality of my voice whatsoever. Mariah has been hitting these notes at an early age and she's never had any problems because of them - her problems are because of getting older and her nodules.
The whistle register is a separated register like the falsetto so transitioning from any voice to the whistle register is extremely difficult.
I would suggest hold a note, a comfortable note, and use the techniques to go into whistle register to see if you can transition like that. If you can't do it with your chest voice, try your mixed, full, and head voice.
If you cannot transition with any of your voices then it's totally fine. Perhaps you're just not meant to and that's perfectly fine. Take a second and hit the high notes comfortably instead of "forcing", in a sense, yourself to transition.
Keep practicing and STOP whenever you feel any strain. And remember, we can't all be Mariah Carey! Sean September 15, at am There are two ways of producing 'whistle tones': The connected high head voice extension, and the disconnected whistle register. Whether or not Mariah's nodules are due in part to factors other than her technique, it's a fact that extensive breathy, airy singing as she frequently does in mixed voice, head voice, and whistle register will contribute to one's vocal downfall, as it is simply not a healthy way to repeatedly vocalize.
To her credit, she has the ability to manipulate her timbre from light and airy to solid and clear, and has unsurpassed vibrato control up to the seventh octave, etc. It's a pity about her voice and its inconsistency due to gradual deterioration, to be honest.
Abdul September 19, at pm Ok so I'm a 16 year old guy and I wanna learn how to sing whistle notes, I use this note recognizer app and I hit F6 but it wasn't whistle, it was a squeak and I felt tension on my thoat every time I try whistle notes, I tried your method and I just I always feel tension when I try whistle tones, please help I want to be one of the only famous male singers who have that register September 20, at am Hi Abdul - have you worked with a voice teacher?
Or, give us a call at and we can help you find one! I never had a vocal teacher because i didn't get good teacher in my city. I can sing in whistle register. Its not a falsetto or a very high head voice. I just found it some days ago. I didn't believed it was my whistle register so i never worked on it.
But now I'm sure about it.. I can easily do it it but something like rough vibrato or scratch comes somtimes when i try to sing low. How can I get rid of this? October 26, at am Hi there! We really recommend working with a vocal teacher, who can listen to your voice as you sing and help you with the "scratch" you mention. We also offer online lessons, so you can connect with professional teachers all across the US. Give us a call at and we'll be happy to get you set up!
Antonis November 14, at am I have a problem with my wistle register I am 15 years old and I like whistle register The problem is that I can't reach whistle notes with my head looking straight I press myself a lot and I always bend my head over to reach these notes November 14, at am Hi Antonis! Have you worked with a voice teacher on this?
We really recommend that. You can browse our teacher profiles online, or have your parents call us at to set up lessons. Famous Vocal Coaches November 18, at am Thank you for your post! This tutorial is fabulous! Lots of great info including, Finding a voice teacher is not an easy task—especially if you live outside a major metropolitan area. Put simply, good Famous Vocal Coaches are few and far between—and finding one that is perfect for you can be a challenge. Stanley Carradine November 20, at pm Now, I been wanna gown learn gown to do Whistle note like Jordan fisher and Mariah and marrisotn and arianna Grande and have been watching video and only one video made me hear Whistle but it never work own that I did the technique one line, I can actually jere my self produce a whistle like quite one.
Antonis November 28, at am Suzy S. The problem is that I am from Greece and it is very difficult to find a vocal coach who knows about whistle register in this country In Greece there are not singers who care about whistle register and when I ask a vocal coach about whistle notes they tell me that there is no reason to have knowledge on that What can I do for that? If you are having difficulty finding a local vocal coach who can help with your specific goals - I would encourage you to consider online lessons.
Online lessons would allow you to learn from someone who may be in another country but can offer tips on how to appropriately use the whistle register.
There are also videos online that provide further information about the whistle register and how to safely use this voice. I hope this helps you! Thats really work Famous Women Singer December 30, at am i am practicing alot with my singing and could use some guidance. Luna February 07, at am I managed to hit the whistle register on 2 separate occasions while randomly trying to sing Mariah Carey songs before I came to this website, but currently I am unable to hit the whistle register again and I'm not sure why..
A little advise here? Antonis February 07, at am Can you give me some advice to help me having my larynx relaxed when i try to hit whistle notes? Jessica Dais June 06, at pm Hello! Whistle notes can be some of the most complex high notes to hit. If you're a preteen, the best thing I can recommend is to take singing lessons to further develop your vocal chords. Guidance from an experienced teacher will also ensure that you're not damaging your voice with improper techniques.
Have your parent or guardian call in to find out more about private singing lessons in your area! You can reach us at Hope that helps!
Prince Rahn June 22, at am Hi, my name's Rahn. I'm practicing whistle, but I can't hit at all yet, tho I'm sure if I practice, I'll get there. In head voice, I can go up about D6, and higher if I push a little harder.
My highest is F6 or F 6 so far. I used to whistle all the time when I was younger, but as I got older, I naturally lost it. Are there any other tips, aside from the ones above, that you can give me? If so, I'd highly appreciate it. Jessica Dais June 22, at pm Hi Rahn! If you can already sing that high, whistle notes aren't too far out of your reach.
I highly recommend working with a vocal coach to push yourself a little bit further, while protecting your voice at the same time.
Call us at to find an experienced singing teacher in your area! Hope that helps :. Carmi Nazario July 04, at pm Hi, there, qualified whistle register teachers! I can't sustain whistle register notes so please help me how to practise everything about whistle register notes in very professional ways.
0コメント